Age Appropriate Censoring Is Not The Same As Banning.

As a parent, I’m faced with the question of what to censor and what not to censor pretty much every single day. From songs to books to movies I have to evaluate pretty much everything. This is the way of the world and while it’s a pain in the butt sometimes, it’s part of being a parent. I consider myself pretty liberal in most ways but I am not going to give my small kids free range to watch or read or listen to anything. Censoring things until my kids are the appropriate age to understand what they are seeing isn’t the same thing as banning it. I’m not saying that they will never get to choose for themselves. I’m not saying that I will go to war with my kids over music or movies with moral superiority. I am saying that at four and two, my kids aren’t mature enough to decide what they see or hear. 

I’m not trying to put them in a bubble and keep them ignorant of the perils of humanity. However, I am trying to make sure that when they are faced with a serious topic, they are of a mind to understand it and make whatever peace they need to with it. 

I recently saw a post in a mom’s group on Facebook that asked for some advice on censoring. The child was seven and had been watching the Netflix series “Shameless”. I’ve watching quite a bit of these episodes and in no way think it’s at all appropriate for a seven year old. However, the Mother in question was asking what to do now that her child had already seen some of it. Should she ban the child from watching further? How should she broach the subject of what the child had already seen? I gave my advice there and I’ll give it here since it’s pretty universal.

What the child has already seen can’t be unseen so ignoring a subject isn’t going to help anyone. I would start with asking the child if they have any questions about what they saw. That way you don’t bust into topics that aren’t a worry but still address what the child is curious or conflicted about. Also, child settings should be put into place on any equipment the child has access to. Keeping an eye on your child isn’t invading their privacy. It’s taking care to make sure your child is introduced to subjects at the right time.

giphy7

Banning something out right is a whole different matter. Intentionally withholding information due to religious bias isn’t alright. It’s not your right to force your kid into believing as you do. They don’t belong to you. They are not your canvas to paint as you see fit. They deserve the right to disseminate the information in their own way and make their own conclusions. Banning them from reading freaking Harry Potter isn’t going to win you any points. It just makes you an asshole who is afraid that your world view won’t hold up under some scrutiny. 

giphy6

I can’t think of much that I would outright ban in my home. My kid wants to read about the holocaust when they’re older? Sure, lets look at the information. My kid wants to study Satanism? Sure, lets check it out and see what’s going on. Kid wants to go to a Church or Mosque? Why not. Lets go on an adventure. Interested in bondage sex? Polyamory? At the right age, I’m here to talk about what’s on your mind. These are opportunities for me to talk about consent or religion or the horrors humanity has wrought. These are opportunities for me to be the parent who turns out an educated and confident human. A human who doesn’t get rapey at the sight of a scantily glad person. A human who doesn’t distrust and hate another because they have a different skin color or speak a different language. 

When you ban a book or a movie or a song, what you’re really doing is taking away your kids ability to have empathy for another. You’re taking away the chance that they will see another person as another person and not buy into some nonsensical stereotype. You’re taking away the chance to build self esteem in your kid and you’re taking away a chance for them to find who they are in the safety of a parent relationship. 

So, think about it before you swing that ban hammer. The consequences could be more than you bargained for.

giphy5

 

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Age Appropriate Censoring Is Not The Same As Banning.

  1. True. At the library where I work, we celebrate Banned Book Week by displaying books than have been banned for whatever reason. It’s mostly YA books with magic or sex, because apparently we need to shelter and bubble-wrap our preteen against the horrors of sex. Nonsense! I agree with you that there’s an age factor. I’ve got some Teen Titan graphic novels that my nephew wanted to read, but he’s way too young for the level of violence and language. I told him that he could read them when he was older, which to him meant when he turned a year older.

    Like

    • HAHA! Way to poke all those haters in the eye! The way kids interpret adults has always cracked me up. Just last night my son tricked my hubs and I into cleaning his room by making it a competition. He said whoever picks up the most toys gets a Happy Meal. We caught on to what he was doing but we were so impressed with his cleverness that we played along. His room got clean and he won the contest. We didn’t let him win either. He was like a tornado. Pretty impressive for a 4 year old. 🙂

      Like

  2. I love this post. I don’t have kids of my own, yet, but I like your style and my parents were similar to you. It’s funny that you mention Satanism here because at the age of 17, I found myself interested to find out more after a discussion in a class in school that dealt with all religions of the world. I got myself a copy of the Satanic Bible and read it at home. My parents did ask me what my interest is based on, and made a rather interesting approach (in our family most things are approached lightly, but directly and sometimes where appropriate, through humor so as not to make way for any blockers in the conversation)… I did read the book, I found it interesting and yet, I did not convert into a Satanist… ha. Instead I went on to read about every other religion as well and it opened my eyes to so many viewpoints, overlaps, etc… Anyway, sorry for the personal ramble, I just wanted to say, really, that I love your approach! You’re a great mom by the sounds of it 🙂

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s